Question

The Statement ‘It Is my Duty to Do So and So’ Is not Considered a Vow

206

Question

If one says, " It is my duty to do such and such" instead of saying "It is my duty towards Allah to do such and such", would his saying be considered a vow?

Related Fatwa

If one commits apostasy and then returns to Islam, will his oaths, vows, and rights towards Allah be nullified?

A vow is binding when it suggests commitment

Saying ‘I Will Pray Regularly’ Is Not an Explicit Wording of a Vow

The Statement in the Question Is Not a Vow

Made Too Many Vows and Did Not Fulfil Them

Vowed to Fast 30 Days If She Breaks Her Oath

Making an Unspecified Vow and Supplicating in a Language other than Arabic

Accepted Answer

All perfect praise be to Allah, The Lord of the Worlds. I testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allah, and that Muhammad is His slave and Messenger.

The statement you mentioned, "It is my duty to do so and so," is not an act of Nadhr (i.e., vow), and thus does not indicate obligation. "Not having liability and the non-effectiveness of the vow" is the original ruling on such cases.

Allah knows the best.

Fatwa

The Statement ‘It Is my Duty to Do So and So’ Is not Considered a Vow

Question

Answer

Related Fatwa

If one commits apostasy and then returns to Islam, will his oaths, vows, and rights towards Allah be nullified?

A vow is binding when it suggests commitment

Saying ‘I Will Pray Regularly’ Is Not an Explicit Wording of a Vow

The Statement in the Question Is Not a Vow

Made Too Many Vows and Did Not Fulfil Them

Vowed to Fast 30 Days If She Breaks Her Oath

Making an Unspecified Vow and Supplicating in a Language other than Arabic

Search Fatwa

Fatwa Subject

Categories

Multimedia

Special Folders

Services